← AlgoRishi Blog · algorishi.com

Why your stop-loss didn't fill at the price you set

4 November 2026 · AlgoRishi

You bought a SENSEX call at ₹200. You put a stop-loss at ₹150, so you had decided your loss would be ₹1,000 on one lot. The index turned, the order triggered, and when you opened the position later it said you exited at ₹138.

Your loss was ₹1,240, not ₹1,000. Nobody cheated you. This is slippage, and it is one of the most common reasons a plan that looked tidy on paper bleeds more than expected in a real account.

₹4,000one SENSEX lot at a ₹200 premium
₹20what each ₹1 of premium is worth per lot
0.05smallest price step on the option
15:40 ISTwhen F&O trading closes

A stop-loss is an instruction, not a price

Think of an auto-rickshaw doing 60 on a flyover. You tell the driver, "bhaiya, stop at that next pole." He hears you, he brakes immediately, and he still comes to rest forty metres past the pole.

He obeyed the instruction perfectly. The pole was never the promise — it was only the moment the braking began.

A stop-loss order works the same way. The price you type is the trigger: the level at which the exchange is told to start looking for a buyer for your option. The price you actually get is whatever the best available buyer was paying by the time your order reached the queue. In a quiet market those two numbers are nearly identical. In a fast one they are not.

SENSEX call premium, one fast morning Your SL trigger — ₹150 Bought ₹200 Triggered here Filled ₹138 slip = ₹12 = ₹240 a lot 10:01 IST 10:02 10:03 10:04
The gap between the trigger and the fill is the slippage. It is paid in rupees, not in theory.

The rupee maths on one SENSEX lot

A SENSEX options lot is 20. That single number turns premium points into money: every ₹1 of premium is ₹20 in your account, so a ₹200 premium is ₹4,000 for one lot. It also means slippage is never "just a few rupees."

Exit premiumPoints lost from ₹200Loss on one lot
₹150 — your trigger50₹1,000
₹14555₹1,100
₹13862₹1,240
₹13070₹1,400
Twelve rupees of slippage looks like nothing on a screen. On one lot it is ₹240 — a 24% overshoot of the ₹1,000 you had budgeted. The plan said ₹1,000. The market charged ₹1,240.

Why options slip more than the index itself

The SENSEX index is one number that thousands of people trade. A single option strike is a much smaller market, and strikes come every 100 points, so the crowd is spread thin across dozens of contracts.

At any moment there is a highest price someone will pay and a lowest price someone will accept. That gap is the bid-ask spread. When you exit in a hurry you sell to the highest bidder, whatever it is — and in a sharp move the bidders step back and that gap widens exactly when you need it to be narrow.

Three things make it worse, every time:

SL and SL-M are not the same order

Most Indian brokers offer two kinds. A plain SL order carries a trigger and a limit price: once triggered it becomes a limit order, so it will not sell below the limit you set. A SL-M order carries only a trigger: once triggered it becomes a market order and sells at whatever is available.

The trade-off is symmetric, and worth knowing before the moment arrives rather than during it. SL-M gets you out almost always, at an unknown price. SL protects your price, and in a fast fall it can simply go unfilled — leaving you still holding the option you meant to sell.

Slippage is a cost, not a mistake

A trader who assumes zero slippage has a backtest, not a system. We size every stop in our own SENSEX work knowing the fill will be worse than the trigger, and we treat the difference as a running cost of doing business — the same way a shopkeeper treats wastage rather than pretending it is zero.

Our machine maps support and resistance levels, trades only confirmed breaks, carries a fixed stop-loss, scales part of the position out, and trails a floor behind the rest. Every one of those exits pays some slippage. We would rather publish the number than hide it.

Nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell anything. SENSEX weekly options can lose their entire premium, and SEBI's own studies have found that the large majority of individual F&O traders in India lose money over a year. Slippage makes a losing plan lose faster; it does not turn one around.

What to check in your own records

The honest version of this question is answerable from your own order book. For your last ten stop-loss exits, write down the trigger you set and the price you actually received, and multiply the difference by 20.

Most traders have never added that column up. It is usually the quietest leak in the account, and the only one you can measure without an opinion.

Disclosure: AlgoRishi publishes signal tracking on real market prices using virtual capital, for information and education only. Nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to trade. Futures & options trading involves substantial risk of loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. AlgoRishi is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser or research analyst.