You have ₹10,000 to spend and a view on SENSEX for this week. Do you buy one near-the-money option, or four cheap far-away ones? This is the question almost every options buyer in India gets wrong at the start, and the answer is entirely arithmetic.
A SENSEX options lot is 20 units, and strikes are listed every 100 points. That is it. Everything below is those two facts plus multiplication.
What you pay is the premium times 20. A ₹200 premium costs ₹4,000. A ₹40 premium costs ₹800. The tick size is 0.05, so the smallest possible flicker in the quote is one rupee of your money per lot.
An at-the-money option is a metered auto. You pay the full fare up front, it is expensive, and it almost certainly gets you moving the moment the traffic clears.
A far out-of-the-money option is a shared auto that only departs once six passengers show up. It costs a fraction of the fare. But if the sixth passenger never arrives, you do not get a partial ride and a partial refund — you get nothing, and you have lost the whole fare.
Both are legitimate ways to travel. People get hurt because they buy the shared auto, then expect it to behave like the metered one.
Suppose SENSEX is trading around 84,300 on a Monday, and you have a view that it drifts higher into Thursday's expiry. The strikes available to you sit at 84,300, 84,400, 84,500 and so on, every 100 points. Take three illustrative call options — the premiums below are made up for teaching, not quotes.
| Strike | Distance | Premium | Cost of 1 lot | Index needed at expiry |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 84,300 (at the money) | 0 | ₹250 | ₹5,000 | above 84,550 |
| 84,600 (out of the money) | +300 | ₹120 | ₹2,400 | above 84,720 |
| 85,000 (far out) | +700 | ₹40 | ₹800 | above 85,040 |
The last column is the one nobody looks at. It is just strike plus premium: 84,600 + 120 = 84,720. To merely break even on that cheap-looking ₹120 option, SENSEX has to travel more than 400 points in your direction by Thursday. The ₹40 option needs over 700 points. The ₹5,000 at-the-money option needs 250.
Cheap did not mean easy. Cheap meant the market was telling you it considered that outcome unlikely.
When you pay ₹250 instead of ₹40, you are buying responsiveness. An at-the-money option reacts to the very next 100 points of index movement. A 700-point-away option barely reacts at all until the index comes to it.
That matters enormously if you use a stop-loss. Put a 30% stop on a ₹250 premium and you are risking ₹75, which is ₹1,500 on one lot — a defined, survivable number. Try the same discipline on a ₹40 option and your stop is ₹12, inside the normal noise of the quote. You will be stopped out by nothing happening at all.
SENSEX weeklies and monthlies both expire on Thursday. An option is part intrinsic value and part time value, and the time-value half shrinks every single day — slowly on Monday, brutally on Wednesday and Thursday.
The F&O session closes at 15:40 IST, and expiry-day decay is sharpest in those final hours. Far out-of-the-money options are almost entirely time value. So they are the ones that bleed hardest as expiry closes in. By Thursday afternoon, an 85,000 call with the index at 84,400 is not a cheap lottery ticket any more; it is a melting one. This is why so many traders describe buying options as "the premium just vanished" — it did not vanish, it was always going to, and they bought the strike where that happens fastest.
We do not pick a strike because it is affordable. We decide how far the index plausibly travels if our level actually breaks, then choose a strike whose breakeven sits comfortably inside that distance. If no strike does, there is no trade — the move we are imagining is not big enough to pay for the option.
Running it in that order, rather than starting from what fits the budget, changes the question from "what can I afford?" to "what does this move have to do for me to get paid?" The second question has an answer you can check.
Four questions, all arithmetic, all answerable before you buy. Most of the damage in options buying happens because the third one is never asked.