You have seen the number on every finance reel: 93% of F&O traders lose money. It gets quoted as a warning, as a joke, and occasionally by the same people selling you a tips channel.
Almost nobody quotes what the study around it actually measured. So let us go through it properly, because the detail is far more useful than the headline.
India's market regulator, SEBI, has published more than one analysis of how individual traders fare in equity derivatives. The widely quoted one came out in September 2024 and covered the three financial years from FY22 to FY24, looking at over one crore individual traders.
Its central finding: roughly 93% of those individual traders made a net loss over that period. An earlier study, covering FY22 on its own, had put the figure near 89%. The direction of travel did not improve.
The aggregate is the number that should stop you mid-scroll. Net losses across those individual traders came to about ₹1.8 lakh crore over three years. Spread across the people who actually lost, that is in the region of ₹2 lakh each.
Buried in the same work is a finding about costs, and it reframes the whole thing.
Traders who lost money paid out an additional sum equal to about 28% of their net trading losses in transaction costs — brokerage, exchange charges, taxes, the lot. That is on top of the losses, not included in them.
Think of an auto-rickshaw in Hyderabad traffic. The meter does not care that you are stationary at a signal. It runs because the engine is on. Transaction costs behave the same way: they are charged for activity, not for being right.
Costs sound abstract until you attach them to a real contract, so take the instrument we follow most closely.
A SENSEX option has a lot size of 20, strikes spaced 100 points apart, and a minimum price movement — one tick — of 0.05.
That tick is where the arithmetic starts. One tick on one SENSEX lot is 0.05 multiplied by 20, which is ₹1. Tiny. Now watch what happens when you trade.
You buy at the offer and you sell at the bid. If the market is two ticks wide, that gap costs you 0.10 on the premium, which is ₹2 per lot on a round trip. Before brokerage. Before any tax.
Still tiny — on one trade. Take ten round trips in a day and the spread alone has quietly charged you ₹20 per lot, every day, win or lose. Over a month of sessions that is a standing bill you never consciously agreed to.
Set that against the position itself: a premium of ₹200 on one SENSEX lot is ₹4,000, since 200 multiplied by 20 is 4,000. The costs are small relative to that. The frequency is what makes them large.
This is where the headline gets abused in both directions, so three clarifications.
It does not say derivatives are rigged. It is a measurement of outcomes across a population, not a claim about anybody's conduct.
It does not say the 7% are skilled. In a sample of one crore people, a slice will finish ahead on luck alone. The study counts winners and losers; it does not certify anybody.
It does not predict what happens to you. A population statistic is not a forecast about an individual. It tells you what the base rate looks like, which is genuinely worth knowing and still not a destiny.
The honest reading is unglamorous. A very wide majority of people doing this lose, those losses are concentrated among people on modest incomes, and activity itself carries a bill of its own.
That combination explains why we are so boring about our own rules: a defined stop before entry, a fixed number of lots, no position held past 15:25 IST, and every session published whether it made money or not. None of that is clever. It is just an attempt to not be the average line in the next SEBI study.
Our own November ledger currently reads ₹0, with no closed trades recorded so far this month. We would rather show you that than a screenshot of somebody's best afternoon.