You buy a SENSEX call at 15:10 IST. The chart looks beautiful. You decide to hold it overnight because the move "is not finished yet".
Next morning at 09:15 the index opens 400 points lower. Your option is worth less than half. There was no stop-loss to hit, because there is no trading between 15:40 and 09:15 — only news.
That is a gap opening. And holding an option through one is not the same trade you entered yesterday. It is a different trade, with a different risk, and it deserves to be treated as such.
The Indian market closes but the world does not. Between 15:40 one day and 09:15 the next, the US market trades a full session, crude oil moves, the rupee moves, a US jobs number prints, a company announces results, a global bank writes something about India.
All of that gets priced into the SENSEX in a single instant at the open. Not gradually over 20 minutes — instantly, in the first print.
Intraday, the index walks. It gives you steps between prices. Overnight, it teleports. Your stop-loss order can only work where there are prices to trade at, so a stop placed at a level the market jumps straight over simply fills at whatever the market is offering when it opens.
One SENSEX option lot is 20 units, so the premium you see is multiplied by 20.
| Step | Premium | Value of one lot |
|---|---|---|
| You buy a call near the close | ₹200 | ₹4,000 |
| Index gaps down at the open | ₹120 | ₹2,400 |
| Difference | −₹80 | −₹1,600 |
You lost ₹1,600 on one lot without a single decision. No bad exit, no panic click, no slippage you could blame on your broker. The loss arrived before you opened your laptop.
And the mirror image is just as real. A favourable gap can double a cheap option overnight. That is exactly why overnight option holding feels so attractive after it works once — the one time it pays, it pays loudly, and the mind files it as skill.
Intraday, you can say "my maximum loss on this trade is 30 points of premium". Overnight, your maximum loss is "whatever the premium is at the open", which could be most of it. Same lot count, completely different risk. If you carry, the size that was sensible yesterday may now be too big.
An option loses value as expiry approaches, and the night is a chunk of that clock that passes while you can do nothing. On SENSEX, weekly and monthly expiry both fall on Thursday, so a Wednesday-to-Thursday overnight hold is the most expensive night in the series: you pay a full night of decay on a contract with hours left to live. The index can open flat and your option can still be worth less.
Many traders learn this the hard way and conclude their broker cheated them. The broker did not. A stop order is an instruction to trade at a price if that price appears. If the market skips the price, the instruction fires at the first price available.
Day fare is metered. You can see the meter, you can ask to stop anywhere, you can get out. Night fare in many cities is negotiated up front, and once you are moving on an empty highway you have no leverage over the price.
Intraday trading is the metered ride. Overnight option holding is the fixed-price night ride. Neither is wrong. But if you pay the night fare believing you are still on the meter, you will be angry at the wrong person in the morning.
It does not. Our book is flat by 15:25 IST, every single day, before the 15:40 F&O close. That is not because carrying overnight cannot work — it is because we chose a method whose stop-loss has to be honoured by an actual tradeable price, and a gap makes that promise impossible to keep.
That is a design choice with a cost. We give up every overnight continuation move, and some of them are big. We would rather miss those than own a risk we cannot measure before we take it.
None of the above is a recommendation to hold or not hold. It is a description of what changes mechanically when a position crosses the night, so you can decide with the arithmetic in front of you instead of after the open.